Invalid Appeal: 76561198152583215 - (wash / SR CAUTION)

Appeal for SR CAUTION

Steam profile: 76561198152583215 (wash)

Appeal Plea: I am innocent of all listed offenses
Appeal Reason: [Evidence] Fake - Report had falsified evidence

Victim Repayment: No, I committed no fraud or had no direct victims
Previous Appeals: No, this is my first appeal here​

Alternate Accounts:

| steamname: washerewand
| steam3ID: [U:1:236064095]
| steamID32: STEAM_0:1:118032047
| steamID64: http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198196329823
| customURL:
| steamrep: http://steamrep.com/profiles/76561198196329823

I originally forgot my password to my main account so I created anymore temporary account and used it from time to time because I bought games on it and occasionally let my little brother and friends use it.​

Appeal description:

Ok so back when I had a larger inventory and enjoyed a youtuber named TheProphet who got scammed by a phishing link I decided to track down and donate to him the exact hat he had which was his say "prized possession." This is the video in which he made of it. )) So he is a fairly popular youtuber and was at the time as well. So I got a lot of people coming to me saying +rep or "what a good guy you are here have this" *small donation of item(s)." So then after a bit I got an friend request from this guy named McLovin which was another username at the time that I cannot recall. We played together quite a bit and after a while he decided to donate to me. (probably a couple weeks went by after adding me to say thank you about helping that guy get his hat back) And this is when the guy DONATED ME 230$! Essentially his whole backpack which was 3 unusuals 12 keys and a strange demoman cosmetic. Now I was taken away by this and obviously accepted becuase that is a large amount of money I realized but my immediate thoughts were not "this guy is gonna pull something on me" because I have had him added for a bit. I did not particularly like those unusuals but I almost right away traded them for a couple autralium weapons but i had to overpay for them. So the value of the items which he gave me significantly went down due to me overpaying for other more desirable items. And then he asked for them back... he wanted 230$ in items back... I found this completely unreasonable because I would have had to take some of my inventory value to give back to this guy. I would have been down even more money after helping the youtuber out also if I returned the amount in which he donated to me. And I would like to point out the "evidence and claims" put against me. First the screenshots of the conversation with Ace was his name at the time or still is. When I saw that McLovin was taking this action against me I was very suprised and taken back and like most other people would I got worried and asked other people if that method actually was scamming. And most of my close friends said it was scamming so i got really worried. So originally I was gonna try to trade to get the amount back and give that 230$ in items back to him. So I went to trade with my friend Ace and he noticed -trust ratings on bp.tf so I explained the situation and I "admitted to scamming" but it WASN'T scamming which after I had talked with another friend that was big with trading said that it wasn't which I now know that not giving back a donation isn't a scam. There was a fake convo that was created by one of his friends. And now onto Scott the person I supposedly stole the earbud from. The convo he listed as evidence isn't real I can tell you. It's not a screenshot so he could have made it up which he did but deciding that is up to you. We fair and square exchanged items and he was being really verbally abusive throughout the conversation. Calling me different names and racial slurs but i'm not here to report that. As well with the McLovin situation I thought I scammed him at first because he told me the code didn't work then blocked me.

So those are my two cases explained this situation is obviously your call here.
Here is some other evidence to appeal situation.
The claim he made on harpoon gaming was declined:
https://forum.harpoongaming.com/threads/scam-report-76561198152583215-washerewand.14921/

Here is a screenshot of the chat saying he donated the items:

Thank you steamrep!
I am open to you asking me any questions at all I realize this was a long time ago but would like to clear my record for trading.​