Recently, I was marked SR Caution. I've been looking all over the place for a template or something that I could use... it's like that when you report, correct? Is there even a template?
You're not marked for caution, you just have a pending report. At this point you need to tell the truth(if you scammed or not). If you didn't scam, you'd need to get chat logs and trade history, and anything else you think you have to prove your innocence.
"Q: I've been reported on SteamRep, but I do not have a "BANNED BY SR" yet, what should I do? A: Reply to the open/pending report(s). That is the ONLY way to prevent to be marked. You cannot make an appeal yet, for you do not have been banned yet. Please refrain from making the report a drama thread, that will end bad. Also, a report admin will only soften the punishment if: You're HONEST. You will have to repay to the victim if it was successfull, as soon as possible, without any fuss or w/e. The reporter CANNOT revoke a report. The report admin will weight: Your behaviour The victim's wishes The severity of the offense(s) (or attempts to it). Paying back is NO guarantee to be granted relief of the report, but it IS a requirement. There is no point in asking to be made sure of that, for that will be counted as "fuss" on repay. You already owe the victim, don't make it worse." This will help you
You don't have a tag yet, but it looks like you've already found the report that is showing up on your profile. Here: http://forums.steamrep.com/threads/report-76561198085418805-tf2-team-fortress-2-items.71204/ No need to appeal yet, but you should show evidence that you have paid back everything that was taken.
I want to appeal anyways. It's holding me back from buying anything. Also, I did pay every back from my "scam". There are hundreds of trades of that
José quoted this from our Expanded FAQ, which you can find in the Guides section. I even WROTE that several hours ago.