Declined Report: 76561198039860630 (CAKE)

Scammer:
steamID: CAKE
steamID32: STEAM_0:0:39797451
steamID64: http://steamcommunity.com/profiles/76561198039860630
steamrepURL: http://steamrep.com/profiles/76561198039860630
Info:Attempted to scam. He was saying that he was scammed before by an admin and insist I would go first in a trade (my unusual for Paypal) when I told him he looked suspicious he said that the man who reported him in this post (http://forums.steamrep.com/threads/report-76561198039860630-cake.4843/) was a member of an "enemy" group, the very same group that reported him on tf2outpost. (whatever that means). I told him that he can go first, use a middleman or leave and he kept trying to get me to go first. When I accused him of being suspicious he removed and blocked me. This isn't the first time this fool tried this.

Proof=Conversation:
(picture is attached)
Gandalf the White Horse: also
Gandalf the White Horse: could you tell me the group you are fighting with?
CAKE: thats enough for a payment but i cant i cant get scamed right now
Gandalf the White Horse: Which is why we use a middleman
Gandalf the White Horse: You find one if you want
CAKE: ive gotten scamed by a sorce op admin i m super paranoid
Gandalf the White Horse: Steamrep middlemen
Gandalf the White Horse: There are seven
Gandalf the White Horse: and they do not scam
Gandalf the White Horse: I also ahve server middleman I use frequently
CAKE: i only use my middleman
Gandalf the White Horse: Which?
Gandalf the White Horse: His name?
CAKE: kramaro he owns a server and im admin on his server
Gandalf the White Horse: You have to understand my position
Gandalf the White Horse: You don't trust anyone
CAKE: but its going to take awhile to get him
Gandalf the White Horse: Well I have several middlemen we can use
Gandalf the White Horse: KingJohn
Gandalf the White Horse: PatSilverFox
Gandalf the White Horse: Charmander
Gandalf the White Horse: Bulbasaur
CAKE: sry but i just need u to go first fast ive got like an hour to make my payment
Gandalf the White Horse: payment?
CAKE: ya i owe a guy
Gandalf the White Horse: owe him what?
CAKE: he has alot of colateral on me
Gandalf the White Horse: paypal correct?
CAKE: ya whats your user
Gandalf the White Horse: [email protected]
Gandalf the White Horse: It jsut all seems
Gandalf the White Horse: Fishy
Gandalf the White Horse: What with the tf2outpost report and all
CAKE: its just a group that i was with then they started hating me
Gandalf the White Horse: I'm sorry sir but unless you go first this can't happen, I have more rep than you, I am also a verified tf2 paypal user and you have no rep
CAKE: well im still an admin of that helps?
Gandalf the White Horse: Yo have to understand that just because youre an admin in a server does not mean you can be trusted for that reason alone
Gandalf the White Horse: I have a dozen people to vouch for me
Gandalf the White Horse: and have
CAKE: well an admin has to be trusted thats why i was chosen from a ton of other people
Gandalf the White Horse: Now do you think the fact you are an admin in a server out weighs all my pages of reputation?
Gandalf the White Horse: Be reasonable friend
Gandalf the White Horse: I'm willing to use a middleman
Gandalf the White Horse: But I can't go first, not with your rep
CAKE: if ive gotten scamed by admin on a trade server then i cant trust anyone

why is this still pending?

While fishy, I don't believe that this is enough evidence to say it is a scam attempt.