http://steamrep.com/profiles/76561198064995767 It is said he is an alt of http://steamrep.com/profiles/76561198013601746 There is no evidence that I can see that he is an alt so I am somewhat forced to take your word for it. I have spoken to the user and he has said that his brother ran from a crab 4 years ago. Even if he was an alt, it is said that they ran from a strange part Spy crab 4 years ago, and the evidence isn't really the best. It's mostly chat logs, which can be easily modified. Just to add some more info. - He has been banned as an alt for 4 year for a lowish SpyCrab run - There is no evidence to suggest that he was the person that did the run and only evidence that the same IP was shared - He is saying that it was his brother, there is no evidence that it wasn't his brother - Even if it was him, is a 4 year ban really warranted? - It seems like an invalid ban as from what i understand it's left for the admins on that server to deal with - He has a appeal which hasn't been actioned He is after a dream item of his, my Ethical values tell me I should be able to let him own a dream item but due flaws in the SteamRep system (if indeed he was the brother) then a innocent person is highly being affected here and if he indeed was the runner (no evidence to suggest this) then he is being incorrectly / highly over punished.