Thanks for answering the questions You said you acted like a mediator and they both came to an agreement, the thing is, the scammer didn't agreed to return the stolen items for good deed or because he felt bad about scamming the victim, he returned the items because he had no choice already, either he ran away 2 Buds 1 Bill's short or he agreed to your ultimatum. I mean, what if he don't take the deal and he reports you after you took the items? Doesn't matter if you returned them to the original owner, you scammed him and that's it, whatever the reasoning you have for it. If you goal was to help the victim trading him something for free would been a better course of action in the first place. Going all "Robin Hood" in this kind of economy helps no one, in my opinion. But in the end is up to the admins.